Get information on every U.S. Foundation with one search in FDO Quick Start. It’s free to register!  
Featured Jobs

 

Blog

Is One of Your Professional Goals for 2019 to Serve as a Grant Reviewer?


The pile of proposals to read was daunting. A caffeinated beverage was in one hand, a yellow highlighter and pen in the other. I sat at the dining room table in my apartment wondering what I had signed up for. In the end, some proposals took multiple reads to understand the purpose of the funding and were marked up with question marks and highlighter. Other proposals were crystal clear and were only marked up with exclamation marks of excitement in the margin.
 

In my first cycle of serving as a grant reviewer, which was well before online grant applications were anything more than a beta tested dream, I had a tall stack of hard copy proposals and attachments to read through in one weekend to be prepared for the meeting at the state agency offices on Monday.

Fast forward to serving as a grant reviewer today, and it may now be a file folder full of pdf files to read and notate electronically, but there is still a caffeinated beverage in hand and an electronic highlighter ready to highlight my questions.

Regardless of what specific process a grant professional has the opportunity to serve as a grant reviewer in, whether community foundation, state, federal, or other, the professional development benefit is significant.

Serving as a grant reviewer provides the following benefits to your work as a grant professional:
  • Helps you to experience how you react to different presentation styles;
  • Widens your perspective to see how a diverse group of reviewers react to the same proposal and what common threads of feedback are provided;
  • Strengthens your understanding of the grant review process by letting you see first hand how one process works; and
  • Serves as an opportunity to be inspired by exceptional proposals from other grant professionals.

Now of course, as Philanthropy News Digest published in July of 2018, “If You've Met One Foundation…You've Met One Foundation.” So while serving as a grant reviewer for one grantmaker means you now have a great deal of clarity about the behind the scenes process for *that* grantmaker, you are not able to assume that you can directly apply all those experiences to the next grantmaker. However, you can apply many of the general lessons, and in particular, walk away with the lessons of how you reacted and how your peers in the review process reacted. As a result, the strength of your proposals will be improved overall, and ultimately, the funding success for your organization will reflect your increased competitiveness in the process.

Looking for some more convincing that serving as a reviewer should be a professional goal for 2019? I shared a bit more about the benefit of being a grant reviewer in this video here.

Looking for some ideas on where and how to become a reviewer? Judy Riffle, Ph.D. shared a post here with specific sites to apply through to be considered for federal grant review opportunities.
 
What steps can you take in the upcoming year to strengthen your work as a grant professional by participating as a grant reviewer?
 
Diane H. Leonard, GPC is a Grant Professional Certified (GPC) and Approved Trainer for the Grant Professionals Association. Diane and her team at DH Leonard Consulting & Grant Writing Services have secured more than $50.1 million dollars in competitive grant funds for its clients since 2006. When not working on grant applications, Diane can be found on the water in the 1000 Islands, out for a run, or drinking a strong cup of coffee.

 
 

Comments

 
By: Kathy Parker
On: 11/13/2018 15:18:38
How does one become a reviewer?
 
By: Diane Leonard
On: 11/13/2018 16:18:33
Kathy, If you are interested in being a federal reviewer I would recommend you check out this post from Judy Riffle: https://www.dhleonardconsulting.com/find-federal-grant-review-opportunities/ If you are interested in starting locally, I would recommend reaching out to your local United Way or Community Foundation. If you would like to review at the state level, I would recommend reaching out to agencies you currently work with/your organization is funded by to inquire about how you can serve as a reviewer for application cycles that are not a conflict of interest for you.
 
By: Lisa Tiffin
On: 11/14/2018 08:51:42
Diane - what a great article. This is on my list of next steps in honing my skills.
 
By: Fred Colin Kingston
On: 11/20/2018 16:53:58
Thank you for this article, Diane! I was a grant reviewer, and senior member of the grants committee, for the Yahoo Employee Foundation. It was a valuable experience. (Instead of coffee in one hand, I had tea during those long nights.) I just moved to across the country from California to Kansas. I will contact the United Way to see about becoming a grant reviewer here. Thanks again!
 
By: Diane H. Leonard, GPC
On: 11/25/2018 17:04:35
Fred - Happy to hear about the value that your experience for the Yahoo Employee Foundation played as a professional development opportunity. Looking forward to hearing how your outreach to serve in that capacity for the UW in your new community goes! - Diane

Leave a comment

Please complete the form below to submit a comment on this article. A valid email address is required to submit a comment though it will not be displayed on the site.

HTML has been disabled but if you wish to add any hyperlinks or text formatting you can use any of the following codes: [B]bold text[/B], [I]italic text[/I], [U]underlined text[/U], [S]strike through text[/S], [URL]http://www.yourlink.com[/URL], [URL=http//www.yourlink.com]your text[/URL]